DC Wonder Woman Wonder Woman #7 Review

Wonder Woman #7 Review Kate Fatale http://www.o-r-c.co.uk/media/reviews/photos/thumbnail/400x400s/ab/20/b3/_ww7cov-1334521864.jpg

Written by Kate Fatale     April 15, 2012    
 
3.2
 
0.0 (0)
562   0   1   0   0   0
 

Info

Issue Number
Art (inks)
Art (Colours)
Cover Artist

"Il Gangster Dell'amore"

I don't even...

Plot Synopsis: 

Let's make this short and sweet, because what I have to say about this issue has less to do with its plot (which is lucky, since it doesn't have much of one), and more to do with the way this issue of this title has the potential to sink the entire ship. 

Just when one thinks it can't get any worse, it does.

Diana, Hermes, and Lennox arrive in Italy, where they accost a gangster who turns out to work for Hephaestus. The trio need Hephaestus to arm them so that they can go into Hell to rescue Zola.  Diana's secret plot to distract Hera by getting her to feud with Poseidon and Hades is discussed in one panel; after all, nothing Diana does is important in this story, as this issue makes clear. 

Hephaestus reveals to Diana that she's been lied to yet again and in an even worse way. Turns out the Amazons are an all-female society because they seduce sailors, get pregnant, and only keep the children if they're girls. Boys are traded with Hephaestus for weapons; otherwise, the Amazons would just drown them. Finding out they're all her brothers, Diana tries to liberate the men who work for Hephaestus, only to be told that they like where they're and don't need her. Diana is crestfallen. Hephaestus comforts her by advising her to rest up, since tomorrow she'll literally be going to Hell. 

Editor review

Story: 0.5/5 (half a point since 0 isn't an option)

I'm going to be fairly mean about this one. Consider it tough love, since at the beginning of the Wonder Woman relaunch, I had very high hopes for the title. Previous issues have boasted some very strong moments, and with a writer like Azzarello at the helm, there's been great potential for Wonder Woman to reignite fans' interest. But it's not going to happen with this issue...

DC's New 52 has had some real duds, especially where female characters are concerned, but I feel perfectly confident in calling this issue the single worst thing that has happened so far. I barely know what to say about it, other than that everything about is horrible.

The seventh issue of the new series makes a few things very clear: in the new DCU Wonder Woman isn't a strong warrior, nor even a dignified princess. She's just a girl who's been tricked into believing she and her people are something special. Luckily, there are men around her to tell her the truth. How good of them. As a woman who has been a comics fan since childhood, I'm so glad DC has rewritten the story of the ONLY woman in the entire DCU who stands on equal ground with Superman and Batman so that she's just a powerless little idiot whose only talent is occasionally befuddling deities. I'm absolutely ecstatic that the woman who is perhaps the most famous fictional feminist icon has been reduced to utter powerlessness. I think it's wonderful that her society, which has previously been built on principles of sisterhood and which had an understandable reason for prohibiting men to set foot on their island, has been rewritten to be a group of sirens who literally would kill male children just for being male. Yes, DC, that's what we women readers want to see. We want to be reminded that women really can't be heroes, and that a woman can only appear (but never actually be) strong if she's a stereotypical "man-hater." Gee, thanks.

Moreover, thanks for being so gracious and kind as to include a lowly woman like Diana in a comic book about Zeus's family. That's really swell of you.

It seems as if every issue of the title, and this one especially, involves Diana being put in her place by male characters. She wields no authority. She's literally told in this issue that her signature weapons are actually useless. she doesn't do anything. She just stands around, immeasurably hurt by yet another revelation that the women in her life are all sadistic liars and the only people she can rely on are the men of the Greek pantheon.

And nothing else really happens. If Diana's going to have a crisis of identity, can it at least wait until her identity has been established? New readers coming into this title will have no idea who Wonder Woman is supposed to be, but they will know that she's apparently not much of anything.

Here's hoping #8, in which Diana goes to Hell, will see the Amazon warrior reclaiming her power as a superheroine.

Art: 4/5

The art was good, but overshadowed by the horrifyingly ridiculous story. I rather liked the character design for Hephaestus, and with Cliff Chiang returning for the interior art, the awkward facial expressions that marred the past issue are gone. Great art, but it's hard to get excited about it when it's accompanied by this story. However, on a positive note, while the character design for Hades is hit-or-miss, I'm quite looking forward to seeing Hell in the next issue.

Cover: 5/5

Art-wise, it's a great cover. Hephaestus's arm lends a grotesque element to a scene of Diana, face grave and resolute, forging a weapon. If the cover were in any way indicative of the storyline, it would undoubtedly have been a great issue. As has happened with the past couple of issues, this one places Diana in a position of strength she never actually attains in the story...ever. However, it's great art.
Overall rating 
 
3.2
Art 
 
4.0
Covers 
 
5.0
Story 
 
0.5
Kate Fatale Reviewed by Kate Fatale April 15, 2012
Top 50 Reviewer  -   View all my reviews (20)

Wonder Woman #7 Review

Story: 0.5/5 (half a point since 0 isn't an option)

I'm going to be fairly mean about this one. Consider it tough love, since at the beginning of the Wonder Woman relaunch, I had very high hopes for the title. Previous issues have boasted some very strong moments, and with a writer like Azzarello at the helm, there's been great potential for Wonder Woman to reignite fans' interest. But it's not going to happen with this issue...

DC's New 52 has had some real duds, especially where female characters are concerned, but I feel perfectly confident in calling this issue the single worst thing that has happened so far. I barely know what to say about it, other than that everything about is horrible.

The seventh issue of the new series makes a few things very clear: in the new DCU Wonder Woman isn't a strong warrior, nor even a dignified princess. She's just a girl who's been tricked into believing she and her people are something special. Luckily, there are men around her to tell her the truth. How good of them. As a woman who has been a comics fan since childhood, I'm so glad DC has rewritten the story of the ONLY woman in the entire DCU who stands on equal ground with Superman and Batman so that she's just a powerless little idiot whose only talent is occasionally befuddling deities. I'm absolutely ecstatic that the woman who is perhaps the most famous fictional feminist icon has been reduced to utter powerlessness. I think it's wonderful that her society, which has previously been built on principles of sisterhood and which had an understandable reason for prohibiting men to set foot on their island, has been rewritten to be a group of sirens who literally would kill male children just for being male. Yes, DC, that's what we women readers want to see. We want to be reminded that women really can't be heroes, and that a woman can only appear (but never actually be) strong if she's a stereotypical "man-hater." Gee, thanks.

Moreover, thanks for being so gracious and kind as to include a lowly woman like Diana in a comic book about Zeus's family. That's really swell of you.

It seems as if every issue of the title, and this one especially, involves Diana being put in her place by male characters. She wields no authority. She's literally told in this issue that her signature weapons are actually useless. she doesn't do anything. She just stands around, immeasurably hurt by yet another revelation that the women in her life are all sadistic liars and the only people she can rely on are the men of the Greek pantheon.

And nothing else really happens. If Diana's going to have a crisis of identity, can it at least wait until her identity has been established? New readers coming into this title will have no idea who Wonder Woman is supposed to be, but they will know that she's apparently not much of anything.

Here's hoping #8, in which Diana goes to Hell, will see the Amazon warrior reclaiming her power as a superheroine.

Art: 4/5

The art was good, but overshadowed by the horrifyingly ridiculous story. I rather liked the character design for Hephaestus, and with Cliff Chiang returning for the interior art, the awkward facial expressions that marred the past issue are gone. Great art, but it's hard to get excited about it when it's accompanied by this story. However, on a positive note, while the character design for Hades is hit-or-miss, I'm quite looking forward to seeing Hell in the next issue.

Cover: 5/5

Art-wise, it's a great cover. Hephaestus's arm lends a grotesque element to a scene of Diana, face grave and resolute, forging a weapon. If the cover were in any way indicative of the storyline, it would undoubtedly have been a great issue. As has happened with the past couple of issues, this one places Diana in a position of strength she never actually attains in the story...ever. However, it's great art.

Was this review helpful to you? 
 

User reviews

There are no user reviews for this listing.

Already have an account? or Create an account
 
Powered by JReviews
Posted: 1 year 1 month ago by Adam C #6349
Adam C's Avatar
You're not getting any of the 52?!?!?!?!?!
Posted: 1 year 1 month ago by Winter So1dier #6348
Winter So1dier's Avatar
Adam C wrote:
I love change. :D

WS you're missing out by not reading the title. :o

But if i get Wonder Woman I'll have to get 52 other books (how my mind works)
Posted: 1 year 1 month ago by Chifuyu #6288
Chifuyu's Avatar
I am not afraid of change, not even of big changes. I just dislike it when the title character is pushed to the sidelines and that is what happens in Wonder Woman right now, as Kate already pointed out in her review.

And while I see how the current incarnation of the Amazons is closer to the actual myth, I also think that one should be very, very careful how to adopt it, because most myths are - surprise, surprise - extremely outdated concerning the presented values and set of beliefs. Sometimes these values clash strongly with what we would consider proper and exemplary today. In my opinion, a writer has to be able to balance the myth he wants to introduce and the modern perception of equality, tolerance and proper behaviour. Something in which Azzarello failed quite spectacularly in my opinion.

I don't say change is bad, I say change for the sake of changing is redundant and can backfire. Azzarello could have handled this issue more delicately. I am also pretty sure he mixed up Amazons and sirens, which are two entirely different things.
Posted: 1 year 1 month ago by Adam C #6284
Adam C's Avatar
I love change. :D

WS you're missing out by not reading the title. :o
Posted: 1 year 1 month ago by Winter So1dier #6283
Winter So1dier's Avatar
thehulkster94 wrote:
In my opinion, whether a change is good or bad is all dependent on how it is handled, which takes several months to determine.

True, guess we'll find out in a few!
Posted: 1 year 1 month ago by thehulkster94 #6278
thehulkster94's Avatar
Winter So1dier wrote:
I see your points. But as someone who dislikes big changes to the status quo, i can relate to the feelings of fans who have a problem with this. Not that it really matters to me either way though, I don't even read Wonder Woman lol
True, although almost all great writers change the status quo in a fairly big way, like Peter David on Hulk, or Brubaker on Captain America, both are great, but they both changed the status quo in major ways. Brubaker even brought back one of the 4 or 5 people who were thought to have untouchable deaths.
In my opinion, whether a change is good or bad is all dependent on how it is handled, which takes several months to determine.
Posted: 1 year 1 month ago by Winter So1dier #6277
Winter So1dier's Avatar
I see your points. But as someone who dislikes big changes to the status quo, i can relate to the feelings of fans who have a problem with this. Not that it really matters to me either way though, I don't even read Wonder Woman lol
Posted: 1 year 1 month ago by thehulkster94 #6276
thehulkster94's Avatar
I can understand why people are upset, but I am very neutral on the change. I'm really not focused much on how it differs from past DC continuity, this is a rebooted title. I definitely understand the arguments against this change, but it isn't like there is no basis at all for this, the Amazons of myth were fierce warrior women, and not exactly friendly.
Posted: 1 year 1 month ago by Adam C #6274
Adam C's Avatar
I'm glad with the turn of events. I disliked reading about the glorious amazons so much. They are meant to be strong and brutal and ruthless, just like myth foretold. I'm a bit of a myth freak which makes me bias ha.

I, personally, am so happy with the changes BA has made. Wonder Woman has never been that popular a book and has never captured a general audience. Compared to Batman and Superman, it sucked. However now, it's already critically acclaimed and a fan favourite. Only the other day it got voted one of the top 5 best series to come out in 2011 (that includes all the new 52, the digital books, marvel, icon, vertigo, image, boom, dark horse etc. to come out) on crb. It is destroying Superman haha.

As someone who has tried Wonder Woman too many times and hated it (with the exclusion of a few Graphic Novels), I never thought I'd say this, but... Long live Wonder Woman!


(Seriously...)

This is all just my opinion by the way. I understand that it is radically different from what Wonder Woman used to be and that would upset fans who liked the status quo. I also understand that people may just not like this direction.

It's interesting how what can be great for one is horrible for another. I like that we can say how we feel on these forums freely. I know on some forums I'm too scared to post incase war breaks out. I'm looking at you DCforums and CBR) :).

OH just a heads up about reviews. If you're going to post details of the issue, please put a spoiler warning somewhere in the review. Just incase, you know? ^^
Posted: 1 year 1 month ago by Chifuyu #6273
Chifuyu's Avatar
I heard about this on tumblr first and I was shocked! William Moulton Marston is probably turning in his grave. I used to like Azzarello's work, but this is simply offending and disgusting on so many levels.
Posted: 1 year 1 month ago by Winter So1dier #6253
Winter So1dier's Avatar
Wow, I just had to read your review as to why you gave the story a .5/5. It's really too bad they did what they did to such a great female character. Hopefully, they'll re-establish what makes Wonder Woman great in future issues.