DC Other DC Catwoman Issue #1 Review

Catwoman Issue #1 Review Kate Fatale http://www.o-r-c.co.uk/media/reviews/photos/thumbnail/400x400s/a8/e5/cc/_catw1-1324864148.jpg

Written by Kate Fatale     December 26, 2011    
 
3.0
 
0.0 (0)
674   0   1   0   0   0
 

Info

Issue Number
Art (inks)
Art (Colours)
Cover Artist

This review contains spoilers!

The first issue of the rebooted Catwoman is called “...And Most of the Costumes Stay On”, and while this is technically true, the story begins with our anti-heroine’s costume mostly off. In every panel of the first page, we see Selina’s red bra and ample cleavage as she frantically packs up her apartment to escape a gang of masked men. Even as the men burst through the door and begin firing at her, leaving her no choice but to jump out the window, her sleek black suit is still partially unzipped. Page 3 marks the first time we actually see her face.

So far, we can’t be sure if the first issue’s story will be more concerned with the men who are chasing Selina or Selina’s varying stages of undress. The latter will soon win out.

Selina seeks refuge at the apartment of an old friend, Lola. (Yes, Winick goes out of his way to make a reference to "Copacabana" here.) Lola is clearly aware of Selina’s double life and even seems to share her affinity for cats. Lola then acts as dispatcher, sending Selina to perform reconnaissance work at a nightclub frequented by a Russian mob. Rather beautifully disguised in a red wig, Selina tends the bar and uses her fluency in Russian to eavesdrop on mobsters’ conversations. Just as she finds information that interests her (a priceless painting), she recognizes the voice of a man called Renald. Startled, she remembers watching Renald kill an as-yet-unnamed woman in front of her when she was a child.

She follows Renald into the men’s bathroom, where she opens her shirt—revealing a purple bra this time—and distracts Renald with the sight of her half-naked body, then attacks him, ruthlessly slashing his face with her nails. Once she’s done with him, the real bartender of the club has been found, unconscious and tied up, leaving Selina no choice but to escape the club as Catwoman. It’s a shame that this part of the scene is so short; given the brutal flashback we just witnessed, it seems that Selina’s retaliation against Renald should receive more emphasis than her showing him her bra. Furthermore, it’s also a shame that both times she dons the Catwoman suit in this issue, it’s because circumstances have forced her to do so, not because she is Catwoman and thus is on Catwoman business. 

 

So far, we can’t be sure if the first issue’s story will be more concerned with the men who are chasing Selina or Selina’s varying stages of undress. The latter will soon win out.

Selina seeks refuge at the apartment of an old friend, Lola. (Yes, Winick goes out of his way to make a reference to the song by The Kinks here.) Lola is clearly aware of Selina’s double life and even seems to share her affinity for cats. Lola then acts as dispatcher, sending Selina to perform reconnaissance work at a nightclub frequented by a Russian mob. Rather beautifully disguised in a red wig, Selina tends the bar and uses her fluency in Russian to eavesdrop on mobsters’ conversations. Just as she finds information that interests her (a priceless painting), she recognizes the voice of a man called Renald. Startled, she remembers watching Renald kill an as-yet-unnamed woman in front of her when she was a child.

She follows Renald into the men’s bathroom, where she opens her shirt—revealing a purple bra this time—and distracts Renald with the sight of her half-naked body, then attacks him, ruthlessly slashing his face with her nails. Once she’s done with him, the real bartender of the club has been found, unconscious and tied up, leaving Selina no choice but to escape the club as Catwoman. It’s a shame that this part of the scene is so short; given the brutal flashback we just witnessed, it seems that Selina’s retaliation against Renald should receive more emphasis than her showing him her bra. Furthermore, it’s also a shame that both times she dons the Catwoman suit in this issue, it’s because circumstances have forced her to do so, not because she is Catwoman and thus is on Catwoman business. 

 

She seeks refuge in a penthouse Lola recommended to her. Batman mysteriously appears behind her. Rather than wasting any time conversing, they begin kissing…and progress from there. Selina’s silent narration informs the reader that while she has no idea who Batman really is and suspects he is similarly ignorant about her, this affair has been ongoing for a while now. The issue ends with a shocking image: Catwoman and Batman, still mostly clothed, making love on the floor.

Editor review

Story: 2/5.
A proper examination of this issue is somewhat problematic. What actually happened in it? Quite a few things, which can be broken up into four scenes: 1) Selina’s escape from her apartment, 2) her meeting with Lola, 3) the nightclub, and 4) her abrupt tryst with Batman. Three of these four scenes, however, seemed to place more emphasis on her underwear than her actions. We know more about Selina’s lingerie than Selina herself with this issue, and while that may not be detrimental to fans who are already familiar with her, new readers might get the mistaken impression that her character is more style than substance.

While we don’t learn what Selina has done to warrant the masked men’s anger, we do get a sense of her dark past. The murder she witnessed as a child is horrifying and reeks of Renald’s misogyny, which Selina seems to prey on when she approaches him in the bathroom. However, the scene could just as easily read as simply another opportunity to ogle Selina’s body. The mix of fan service and characterization isn’t quite balanced in her scene with Renald, and that imbalance risks putting off some readers.

Selina’s sexuality itself isn’t a problem. She’s always been a rather sexual character, Batman’s top femme fatale. Popular depictions of her outside of comics have typically included a sense of sexuality as part of her character (Julie Newmar and Michelle Pfeiffer come to mind). However, these depictions have also featured her personality and actions. We get very, very little of these two elements in this issue. New readers coming to the series who have little previous knowledge of Selina will definitely take away from the issue that she’s sexy, but little—if anything—else. She isn’t wearing her signature suit when she attacks Renald; rather, she’s baring her body to him. When she does don the Catwoman suit, it’s not to commit a heist but to carefully rearrange her leather and zippers so she and Batman can have sex without revealing their true identities to each other. Catwoman, as this issue presents her, is more of a fantasy centerfold than a criminal or anti-heroine.

The sex scene itself might be a little discomforting to readers who aren’t looking for erotica. True, “most of the costumes stay on”, but very little is left to the imagination. Winick and March make it quite obvious where hands and mouths are going, and even the moment of sexual penetration is apparent—in fact, that’s the image with which the issue ends. Regardless of the action sequences (Selina’s actual attack on Renald is excellently creepy), what stands out about the issue is the sex. We’ve seen Batman engaging in erotic trysts before, but his stories focus on action and on plot, not the shape of his Bat-bulge. With Catwoman, we find the opposite happening. The story itself comes second to showing off Selina’s body.

I enjoyed the issue, but I enjoyed it as I might enjoy reading a smutty piece of fanfiction. It definitely comes off more as fan-service than the first issue of a title devoted to one of the most popular DCU characters. To even see Selina as a character in this issue, the reader will have to already be acquainted with her, lest they come away with the impression that she’s the DCU’s version of a Playboy bunny.

A first issue, especially in a completely rebooted universe, has a lot to prove. It asks new readers to give it a try, and it invites old readers to come along on a new journey. It needs to offer both camps of readers a reason to feel that they have made a good decision in trying out this premiere issue, and to encourage them to continue engaging with the story by consuming future issues. I think DC should ask themselves what, exactly, they were trying to communicate to both these camps here, because the message seems to have gotten lost with Selina’s top.

Art: 5/5.
I have to go ahead and confess that I have a weakness for Guillem March’s art. I know it isn’t to some fans’ liking, but it catches my eye and always strikes me as remarkably sensual—which seems appropriate, given his history of creating very cheesecake-y images. Unfortunately, his penchant for facial detail results in a few awkward panels this time, the worst offender being a half-page headshot of Selina looking very much like she belongs in Poe’s “The Telltale Heart.” However, those moments could very well indicate her catlike nature, as some of her peculiar expressions do seem similar to those we might associate with cats.

March’s talent shines in the issue’s erotic moments. He truly imbues Selina with raw sexuality, and he leaves nothing to the viewer’s imagination in terms of what Selina and Batman are doing to each other. However, though the issue showcases his erotic art, Selina’s attack on Renald is beautifully rendered. Her face becomes truly animalistic as she lashes out against the man who left her with at least one traumatic memory as a child, and it’s in that scene that we visually experience Selina’s power as a femme fatale, as we see this beautiful woman make of herself a weapon.


Cover: 2/5.
Boots, cowl, and cats-eye goggles off, Selina lounges on the roof of a building with her breasts half-exposed, sprinkling diamonds over herself. If she had pulled off one of her signature heists in this issue, the cover would pretty much sum it all up. It’s a pretty cover, but certainly not one of March’s best. In fact, the cover art is probably the weakest art of the entire issue. Fans of March who are accustomed to his elegant, indulgent covers might wonder if he was feeling extremely rushed when he created this one.

Overall rating 
 
3.0
Art 
 
5.0
Covers 
 
2.0
Story 
 
2.0
Kate Fatale Reviewed by Kate Fatale December 26, 2011
Top 50 Reviewer  -   View all my reviews (20)

Catwoman #1

Story: 2/5.
A proper examination of this issue is somewhat problematic. What actually happened in it? Quite a few things, which can be broken up into four scenes: 1) Selina’s escape from her apartment, 2) her meeting with Lola, 3) the nightclub, and 4) her abrupt tryst with Batman. Three of these four scenes, however, seemed to place more emphasis on her underwear than her actions. We know more about Selina’s lingerie than Selina herself with this issue, and while that may not be detrimental to fans who are already familiar with her, new readers might get the mistaken impression that her character is more style than substance.

While we don’t learn what Selina has done to warrant the masked men’s anger, we do get a sense of her dark past. The murder she witnessed as a child is horrifying and reeks of Renald’s misogyny, which Selina seems to prey on when she approaches him in the bathroom. However, the scene could just as easily read as simply another opportunity to ogle Selina’s body. The mix of fan service and characterization isn’t quite balanced in her scene with Renald, and that imbalance risks putting off some readers.

Selina’s sexuality itself isn’t a problem. She’s always been a rather sexual character, Batman’s top femme fatale. Popular depictions of her outside of comics have typically included a sense of sexuality as part of her character (Julie Newmar and Michelle Pfeiffer come to mind). However, these depictions have also featured her personality and actions. We get very, very little of these two elements in this issue. New readers coming to the series who have little previous knowledge of Selina will definitely take away from the issue that she’s sexy, but little—if anything—else. She isn’t wearing her signature suit when she attacks Renald; rather, she’s baring her body to him. When she does don the Catwoman suit, it’s not to commit a heist but to carefully rearrange her leather and zippers so she and Batman can have sex without revealing their true identities to each other. Catwoman, as this issue presents her, is more of a fantasy centerfold than a criminal or anti-heroine.

The sex scene itself might be a little discomforting to readers who aren’t looking for erotica. True, “most of the costumes stay on”, but very little is left to the imagination. Winick and March make it quite obvious where hands and mouths are going, and even the moment of sexual penetration is apparent—in fact, that’s the image with which the issue ends. Regardless of the action sequences (Selina’s actual attack on Renald is excellently creepy), what stands out about the issue is the sex. We’ve seen Batman engaging in erotic trysts before, but his stories focus on action and on plot, not the shape of his Bat-bulge. With Catwoman, we find the opposite happening. The story itself comes second to showing off Selina’s body.

I enjoyed the issue, but I enjoyed it as I might enjoy reading a smutty piece of fanfiction. It definitely comes off more as fan-service than the first issue of a title devoted to one of the most popular DCU characters. To even see Selina as a character in this issue, the reader will have to already be acquainted with her, lest they come away with the impression that she’s the DCU’s version of a Playboy bunny.

A first issue, especially in a completely rebooted universe, has a lot to prove. It asks new readers to give it a try, and it invites old readers to come along on a new journey. It needs to offer both camps of readers a reason to feel that they have made a good decision in trying out this premiere issue, and to encourage them to continue engaging with the story by consuming future issues. I think DC should ask themselves what, exactly, they were trying to communicate to both these camps here, because the message seems to have gotten lost with Selina’s top.

Art: 5/5.
I have to go ahead and confess that I have a weakness for Guillem March’s art. I know it isn’t to some fans’ liking, but it catches my eye and always strikes me as remarkably sensual—which seems appropriate, given his history of creating very cheesecake-y images. Unfortunately, his penchant for facial detail results in a few awkward panels this time, the worst offender being a half-page headshot of Selina looking very much like she belongs in Poe’s “The Telltale Heart.” However, those moments could very well indicate her catlike nature, as some of her peculiar expressions do seem similar to those we might associate with cats.

March’s talent shines in the issue’s erotic moments. He truly imbues Selina with raw sexuality, and he leaves nothing to the viewer’s imagination in terms of what Selina and Batman are doing to each other. However, though the issue showcases his erotic art, Selina’s attack on Renald is beautifully rendered. Her face becomes truly animalistic as she lashes out against the man who left her with at least one traumatic memory as a child, and it’s in that scene that we visually experience Selina’s power as a femme fatale, as we see this beautiful woman make of herself a weapon.


Cover: 2/5.
Boots, cowl, and cats-eye goggles off, Selina lounges on the roof of a building with her breasts half-exposed, sprinkling diamonds over herself. If she had pulled off one of her signature heists in this issue, the cover would pretty much sum it all up. It’s a pretty cover, but certainly not one of March’s best. In fact, the cover art is probably the weakest art of the entire issue. Fans of March who are accustomed to his elegant, indulgent covers might wonder if he was feeling extremely rushed when he created this one.

Was this review helpful to you? 
 

User reviews

There are no user reviews for this listing.

Already have an account? or Create an account
 
Powered by JReviews