DC Other DC Catwoman #3 Review

Catwoman #3 Review Kate Fatale http://www.o-r-c.co.uk/media/reviews/photos/thumbnail/400x400s/01/ba/dc/_catw3-1324930409.jpg

Written by Kate Fatale     December 26, 2011    
 
3.0
 
0.0 (0)
589   0   1   0   0   0
 

Info

Issue Number
Art (inks)
Art (Colours)
Cover Artist

This review contains spoilers.

Plot:
Flashback-- A slightly younger Selina happily presents Lola with expensive jewelry she’s just stolen. Lola warns Selina that she should be more careful. Back in the present, Selina, her eyes huge with shock, is bound to a chair by Bone’s men. Bone monologizes about his crappy childhood, relating that he spent most of his youth in a group home, where the other children regularly stole from him. After he became an adult, he made a point to surround himself with material goods, some of which Selina has recently stolen.

And that’s it. His entire motivation for killing Lola and beating Selina within an inch of her life lies in his feeling offended that he has once again been targeted for theft. Certainly anyone would be angry if they were robbed, but given his frightening exterior, the strength of his men, and the violence he has ordered against Selina and Lola, his reasons come off as terribly anticlimactic…and kind of stupid.

After ranting about why he of all people should not be stolen from, he orders his men to torture Selina to death. Once again, all that effort for relatively nothing. He already has information on the people to whom Lola sold the stuff Selina stole from him, but he apparently wants her tortured to death as revenge.

The men flip her chair over, and somehow that’s enough for Selina to break the chair legs with her own. She overpowers one of the men and pulls his own gun on him. She demands that the henchmen tell her where Bone has gone, and when at first they don’t comply, she shoots two of the men through their kneecaps, then threatens the genitalia of the third.

She finds Bone in an exclusive nightclub, receiving a lapdance. Like the Russian clans of the previous two issues, this Catwoman nemesis loves the attention of nearly-naked women. At this point, I feel we might begin questioning why each issue seems to involve some form of women selling themselves. Is this all meant to indicate something about Selina’s past? It certainly wouldn’t be very surprising, as we’ve seen her involved in prostitution before. Furthermore, Selina tells Bone that she grew up in much worse circumstances than he, leaving us to wonder if the overt sexuality of each issue is supposed to point toward a history of sexual abuse. However, with these scenes’ emphasis on the seductiveness of the women, it could just as easily be read as eye candy, not suggestive exposition.

Hauling Bone out onto a rooftop, she proceeds to beat him, citing his murderous materialism as the reason she ultimately seeks to kill him. However, Batman intervenes. He tries to convince Selina that killing Bone won’t help her, and that furthermore, he can’t forgive her that particular crime. Selina distracts him with a kiss and uses her whip to knock Bone over the edge of the roof, knowing that Batman will be forced to go after him instead of chasing her.

Back at Lola’s apartment, Selina sets a fire to destroy all evidence of her connection to her deceased friend. Photographs of them together establish a close and positive past. Leaning down to kiss her friend’s face, Selina thinks she hears Batman behind her and turns to find that the police have found her.

Editor review

Story: 3/5
As already discussed above, Bone’s cheap motivation makes the main conflict of this issue rather lackluster, especially when we consider the violence for which he was responsible in the previous issue. Given his appearance and the extreme efforts of his men to find (and then hurt) Selina, I was really expecting something more than a childish tantrum. To move beyond Catwoman for a moment, other titles of the New 52 have begun with strong, frightening villains whose motivations are either mysterious or frightening. Bone had the potential to be among these villains, especially with all the effort that went into establishing his deformed appearance, but if this is Bone’s climax, it was hardly worth it. It certainly wasn’t worth the sight of Lola’s tortured corpse, or Selina’s graphic beating.

As a big fan of horror, I rather like violence at times, and I don’t think comics should be exempt from showing how brutal the criminals these heroes face can be. However, as with any other medium, there is usually an expectation that there’s something of a balance between the violence depicted and the story surrounding it. That balance is missing here. Bone could have been a much better villain if he hadn’t pitched a fit so childishly. Whether it’s weak writing or just a weak character I don’t know, but either way, it detracted heavily from the issue.

However, Selina’s anger on the rooftop was brilliant, as was her handling of Batman. As weak as half the issue is, the latter half is quite strong.

Art: 3/5.
As much as I like Guillem March, I have to call him out here. I feel that his penchant for cheesecake suits this comic well, despite my misgivings about its imbalanced use of sex, but I do have to agree with one of the criticisms I’ve frequently seen against March’s style, and that’s his occasional weird anatomy. His anatomical problems don’t seem stylistic, for they’re not at all consistent. The nightclub where Selina finds Bone is especially guilty of featuring weird anatomy. Another typical March problem rears its head as well—for all of March’s talent for detail, he does have a bad habit of making all his faces too similar. One of the strippers at the club looks exactly like Selina in a wig.

However, apart from that, the art remains solid. March seems to have tweaked Bone’s appearance a little for this issue, and it’s a major improvement.

In terms of colouring, the final pages back in Lola’s apartment are stunning, as Morey plays the light of the fire against the cool shades of the dark apartment and the night outside. In fact, as gruesome and heartbreaking as that final scene is, artistically it’s the best, in my opinion.

Cover: 3/5.
Selina looks ready to kill (which she is) on the cover, but the contrasting colours make the cover more awkward than stylish. It reminds me a great deal of the colouring issues on the final cover of GOTHAM CITY SIRENS #16 (also drawn by March and featuring Selina).
Overall rating 
 
3.0
Art 
 
3.0
Covers 
 
3.0
Story 
 
3.0
Kate Fatale Reviewed by Kate Fatale December 26, 2011
Top 50 Reviewer  -   View all my reviews (20)

Catwoman #3 Review

Story: 3/5
As already discussed above, Bone’s cheap motivation makes the main conflict of this issue rather lackluster, especially when we consider the violence for which he was responsible in the previous issue. Given his appearance and the extreme efforts of his men to find (and then hurt) Selina, I was really expecting something more than a childish tantrum. To move beyond Catwoman for a moment, other titles of the New 52 have begun with strong, frightening villains whose motivations are either mysterious or frightening. Bone had the potential to be among these villains, especially with all the effort that went into establishing his deformed appearance, but if this is Bone’s climax, it was hardly worth it. It certainly wasn’t worth the sight of Lola’s tortured corpse, or Selina’s graphic beating.

As a big fan of horror, I rather like violence at times, and I don’t think comics should be exempt from showing how brutal the criminals these heroes face can be. However, as with any other medium, there is usually an expectation that there’s something of a balance between the violence depicted and the story surrounding it. That balance is missing here. Bone could have been a much better villain if he hadn’t pitched a fit so childishly. Whether it’s weak writing or just a weak character I don’t know, but either way, it detracted heavily from the issue.

However, Selina’s anger on the rooftop was brilliant, as was her handling of Batman. As weak as half the issue is, the latter half is quite strong.

Art: 3/5.
As much as I like Guillem March, I have to call him out here. I feel that his penchant for cheesecake suits this comic well, despite my misgivings about its imbalanced use of sex, but I do have to agree with one of the criticisms I’ve frequently seen against March’s style, and that’s his occasional weird anatomy. His anatomical problems don’t seem stylistic, for they’re not at all consistent. The nightclub where Selina finds Bone is especially guilty of featuring weird anatomy. Another typical March problem rears its head as well—for all of March’s talent for detail, he does have a bad habit of making all his faces too similar. One of the strippers at the club looks exactly like Selina in a wig.

However, apart from that, the art remains solid. March seems to have tweaked Bone’s appearance a little for this issue, and it’s a major improvement.

In terms of colouring, the final pages back in Lola’s apartment are stunning, as Morey plays the light of the fire against the cool shades of the dark apartment and the night outside. In fact, as gruesome and heartbreaking as that final scene is, artistically it’s the best, in my opinion.

Cover: 3/5.
Selina looks ready to kill (which she is) on the cover, but the contrasting colours make the cover more awkward than stylish. It reminds me a great deal of the colouring issues on the final cover of GOTHAM CITY SIRENS #16 (also drawn by March and featuring Selina).

Was this review helpful to you? 
 

User reviews

There are no user reviews for this listing.

Already have an account? or Create an account
 
Powered by JReviews